What to Do When a Mutual Fund Underperforms: A Comprehensive Guide

Investing in mutual funds is a popular and effective way to grow wealth over time, offering benefits like diversification, professional management, and the potential for strong returns. However, not all mutual funds perform as expected, and it’s not uncommon for investors to encounter underperformance at some point in their investment journey. If you’ve noticed that one of your mutual funds is underperforming, it’s natural to feel concerned or even frustrated. After all, your hard-earned money is at stake, and you want to ensure it’s working as hard as possible for you.

The good news is that underperformance doesn’t always mean it’s time to panic or make hasty decisions. Mutual funds, like all investments, go through cycles of highs and lows, and short-term underperformance may not necessarily indicate a long-term problem. The key is to approach the situation with a clear, informed strategy rather than reacting emotionally. By understanding the reasons behind the underperformance and evaluating your options carefully, you can make decisions that align with your financial goals and risk tolerance.

In this comprehensive guide, we’ll explore what to do when a mutual fund underperforms, providing you with actionable steps to assess the situation and take control of your investments. Whether the underperformance is due to market conditions, changes in fund management, or other factors, this guide will help you navigate the challenges and make informed choices. From analyzing the root cause of underperformance to deciding whether to hold, sell, or switch funds, we’ll cover everything you need to know to protect and grow your investments.

By the end of this guide, you’ll have a clear understanding of how to handle underperforming mutual funds and the confidence to make decisions that support your long-term financial goals. Remember, investing is a journey, and occasional setbacks are a normal part of the process. With the right approach, you can turn underperformance into an opportunity to refine your portfolio and set yourself up for future success. Let’s dive in and explore how to tackle underperforming mutual funds effectively!

---

Why Do Mutual Funds Underperform?

Before diving into solutions, it’s important to understand why mutual funds underperform. Here are some common reasons:

1. Market Conditions

• Example: During a market downturn, even well-managed equity funds may underperform due to broader economic challenges.
• Solution: Assess whether the underperformance is due to temporary market conditions or a deeper issue with the fund.

2. Fund Management Changes

• Example: A change in the fund manager can impact performance if the new manager’s strategy doesn’t align with the fund’s objectives.
• Solution: Research the new manager’s track record and investment philosophy.

3. High Expense Ratios

• Example: Funds with high expense ratios may underperform because fees eat into returns.
• Solution: Compare the fund’s expense ratio with its peers and consider switching to a lower-cost alternative.

4. Sector-Specific Issues

• Example: A sectoral fund focused on technology may underperform if the tech sector faces regulatory challenges.
• Solution: Evaluate whether the sector’s challenges are temporary or long-term.

5. Poor Asset Allocation

• Example: A fund may underperform if it’s overly concentrated in a few stocks or sectors.
• Solution: Check the fund’s portfolio diversification and compare it with its benchmark.

---

Step 1: Analyze the Underperformance

When you notice a mutual fund underperforming, the first step is to analyze the root cause. Here’s how:

1. Compare with Benchmarks

• Check how the fund is performing relative to its benchmark index (e.g., Nifty 50 for equity funds).
• Example: If an equity fund has delivered 8% returns while its benchmark has returned 12%, it’s a sign of underperformance.

2. Evaluate Historical Performance

• Look at the fund’s performance over 1, 3, and 5 years.
• Example: A fund that has consistently underperformed over multiple years may have deeper issues.

3. Check Peer Comparison

• Compare the fund’s performance with similar funds in the same category.
• Example: If a large-cap equity fund is underperforming while its peers are delivering strong returns, it’s a red flag.

4. Review Expense Ratios

• High expense ratios can significantly impact returns.
• Example: A fund with a 2% expense ratio may underperform compared to a similar fund with a 1% expense ratio.

---

Step 2: Assess Your Investment Goals

Before making any decisions, revisit your investment goals:

1. Short-Term vs. Long-Term Goals

• If you’re investing for the long term, short-term underperformance may not be a concern.
• Example: A retirement fund underperforming for a few months may not require immediate action.

2. Risk Tolerance

• Ensure the fund’s risk level aligns with your risk appetite.
• Example: If you’re risk-averse, an underperforming high-risk fund may not be suitable for you.

3. Financial Objectives

• Determine if the fund still aligns with your financial objectives.
• Example: If your goal is capital preservation, an underperforming equity fund may not meet your needs.

---

Step 3: Decide Whether to Hold or Sell

Once you’ve analyzed the underperformance and assessed your goals, decide whether to hold or sell the fund.

When to Hold:

1. Temporary Underperformance
   • If the underperformance is due to short-term market fluctuations, consider holding the fund.
   • Example: A fund underperforming during a market correction may recover when the market stabilizes.
2. Strong Historical Performance
   • If the fund has a strong track record, it may be worth holding despite recent underperformance.
   • Example: A fund that has consistently outperformed its benchmark over 5 years may bounce back.
3. Alignment with Goals
   • If the fund still aligns with your investment goals, consider holding it.
   • Example: A sectoral fund underperforming due to temporary sector challenges may recover in the long term.

When to Sell:

1. Consistent Underperformance
   • If the fund has underperformed consistently over multiple years, it may be time to sell.
   • Example: A fund underperforming its benchmark and peers for 3+ years may not recover.
2. Change in Fund Management
   • If the new fund manager’s strategy doesn’t align with your goals, consider selling.
   • Example: A fund’s performance declining after a change in management may indicate a need to exit.
3. High Expense Ratios
   • If the fund’s high fees are impacting returns, switch to a lower-cost alternative.
   • Example: A fund with a 2.5% expense ratio underperforming compared to a similar fund with a 1% expense ratio.

---

Step 4: Rebalance Your Portfolio

If you decide to sell an underperforming fund, rebalance your portfolio to maintain your desired asset allocation.

1. Reinvest in Better-Performing Funds

• Allocate the proceeds to funds with stronger performance and alignment with your goals.
• Example: Switch from an underperforming equity fund to a well-performing hybrid fund.

2. Diversify Your Investments

• Spread your investments across different asset classes to reduce risk.
• Example: Allocate funds to equity, debt, and international funds for better diversification.

3. Consult a Financial Advisor

• Seek professional advice to ensure your portfolio aligns with your goals.
• Example: A financial advisor can help you identify suitable funds for reinvestment.

---

Step 5: Monitor and Review Regularly

To avoid future underperformance, make monitoring and reviewing your investments a regular habit.

1. Set Review Intervals

• Review your portfolio every 6-12 months or when there’s a significant market change.
• Example: Schedule portfolio reviews in January and July each year.

2. Stay Informed

• Keep up with market trends, fund updates, and economic developments.
• Example: Subscribe to financial newsletters or follow reputable investment blogs.

3. Use Portfolio Tracking Tools

• Leverage tools like Groww, ET Money, or AMC websites to track fund performance.
• Example: Use Groww’s portfolio tracker to monitor your mutual funds in real-time.

Conclusion

Dealing with an underperforming mutual fund can be challenging, but it’s an opportunity to reassess your investments and make informed decisions. By analyzing the underperformance, assessing your goals, and deciding whether to hold or sell, you can protect your portfolio and stay on track to achieve your financial objectives.

Remember, investing is a long-term journey. Stay disciplined, stay informed, and don’t hesitate to seek professional advice when needed.

FAQs